No Rest for the Wicked: Why Joe Paterno Does Not Get A Pass

January 22, 2012 in Crime and Punishment

If you've read the grand jury report surrounding the Jerry Sandusky sex abuse crimes, you'll agree that there are plenty of despicable people at Penn State who should not only be shrouded in public humiliation, but should also do some hard jail time.

To summarize:

  • Sandusky, obviously, his actions so heinous and unforgivable that whatever punishment he gets will never be enough, but I hope we try to outdo ourselves anyway. 
  • Mike McQueary, the graduate assistant who literally laid eyes on Sandusky while he was in the middle of raping a child in the locker room and walked away, having done nothing.
  • McQueary's father, who heard from his son immediately following the locker room incident and decided that the best course of action was to not go to the authorities, but to instead report their discovery to Coach Paterno the next day.
  • There is Tim Curley, Penn State Athletic Director, who waited a week and a half after being notified by Paterno to meet with McQueary, along with Vice President for Finance and Business Gary Shultz, to hear McQueary's findings. The only actions that stemmed from this was for Sandusky's keys to be removed and for the information to be passed along to The Second Mile, a charity founded by Sandusky and used by him to prey on young, troubled boys. 

Many in the media and public have openly vilified the people in this case, so much so that Mike McQueary issued a statement defending his actions. In almost all cases, people agree that everyone involved should be held accountable—except for Joe Paterno. 

In all the situations surrounding Paterno, from his firing from Penn State to his passing earlier today from complications due to lung cancer, most of the comments I hear and statuses that are posted on Facebook and Twitter all seem to resonate with remorse, compassion, and even empathy for the man. Whenever a statement is written denouncing his actions as not enough, several more will reply with variations that all focus on one thing: the success of his career.

"Well I hope Penn St board of trustee are happy now that they didnt [sic] let Joe Paterno finish his final season after all he has done for that school!!! RIP Joe"

"…The man was 85! The last few months shouldn't forever stain his career."

"Jo Pas testimony was that he reported to the two higher ups, as did their testimony confirm this. You can't hold him responsible…"

I call bullshit. His track record with Penn State was indeed impressive, having a winning record that included 409 victories in his time there. However, I as a human being have a hard time reconciling a person's career, money they've donated, or lessons they've taught with the heavily-weighted and final outcome of a terrible decision that forever altered the course of many young lives. What counts more, the men he helped become pro athletes, or the boys that he allowed to be irreparably damaged while he stood by?

Joe Paterno did not do enough, and no amount of rationalization or technicalities is going to change that. The McQuearies, Curley, Shultz, and Paterno, they all share the fact that they did not go to the authorities to have them investigate Sandusky, they did not make any efforts to find out the identity of the child, and they all passed the yoke of responsibility on to others. Except for McQueary's failure to physically step in and stop it, they are all no different. Ivan Maisel of ESPN stated that this scandal "…should zero out neither Paterno's six decades of achievement at Penn State nor his lifetime of leadership and beneficence at the university." Yes, Ivan, that is exactly what should happen. We don't get to rest on our laurels when it comes to doing the right thing, and Joe Paterno should not get a pass for a bad decision that assisted in allowing the continued sexual assault and unspeakable depravity done to children for an additional nine years. 

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/chillbearlatrigue/ Chillbear Latrigue

    Maybe one really serious misjudgment shouldn’t erase all of the good that a person does for the world, but when most of that good surrounds a game and the misjudgment involves child rape, it just does.

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/chillbearlatrigue/ Chillbear Latrigue

    Conversation at the PD gym:

    Cop: “They killed him. They killed the old man.”

    CL: “Possibly.”

    Cop: “You’re okey with that?”

    CL: “I’m not all broken up about it, frenchy.”

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/perverseus/ perverseus

    I’m not a Penn State fan; when it comes to football, I root for the University of Alabama (a requirement of graduation, I think). Had this type of scandal rocked Bama, though, my reaction would be the same: disgust. Yes, Joe Paterno was successful as a college football head coach. Goody for him. That gold star will now be forever tarnished, as it should be. Far too many people in this country put college and professional sports on far too high a pedestal of importance (with the exception of soccer, of course, which is still considered silly and boring by most of us). Joe Paterno did, and now, so are his apologists.

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/chillbearlatrigue/ Chillbear Latrigue

    Is this the kind of infuriating bullshit that you’re talking about, Ducky?

    Killed By Trustees, An example of assholism.

    This was posted by a friend of ours, but as an example of the insanity, so he’s good. This image made my blood boil. A young member of my family recently died of cancer, and I don’t wish that fate on anyone, but fuck you Penn State fan(s) who set up this little display. He was an eighty-five year old man with lung cancer. Let’s not get all accusatory about the cause of death.

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/militantrubberducky/ MilitantRubberDucky

    @ Chillbear Latrigue:
    Yeah, bullshit like that is exactly what I’m talking about. Fucking apologist crap.

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/kausaustralisandsaturn/ Worthless Emo

    I have witnessed the wishy washy beginnings of a monster, and usually it is systematic and subtle like alchoholism. Acedemically, there was some interesting defenses for age gap sexuality and incsest. Such as common reports of romanticizing rape experiences. I was quite surprised and though I found the material interesting, it still gets squished by the arguements of choice, damage, and civility.

    When I was Emo Goddess my platform was for socialism and the criminalization of sports. It sometimes shocks me that I will never feel the support of 30 or so prison clique fat girls behind me again, which was basically an army. We squashed many gym teachers.

    Well done Ducky, standing up against clueless wishy washy … ness and child abuse. I’m still not sure what to call it.