Also, I’ve Never – Eaten A Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich

May 11, 2009 in Also I've Never

In the entire 26 years of my life, I have never eaten a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Often, when I tell people this, they look at me like I am out of my goddamn mind. Similar to the way one might look at a paedophile. I would like to clear the air once and for all and explain why it is that I missed out on this childhood milestone.

When I was about 4 years old, I became completely terrified of wet bread. I was at a family party in someone’s backyard and they had ordered those couple of foot long submarine sandwiches that you get for the super bowl. Anyhow, I was given a piece that had been left out all day much like the food at the deli ( which i refer to strictly as a dysentery bar). Because oil and vinegar was on it, the bread had become soggy and turned pink. Upon eating this rank turkey and Swiss combo, I proceeded to spew. From this moment on, I would forgo all recipes calling for wet bread, such as the aforementioned peanut butter and jell and also, sloppy joe sandwiches.

I have been told numerous times that due to the actual texture of the peanut butter, this sandwich ultimately is not wet. This apparently involves crystallization and physics, things which I am too slow to understand. To be frank, unless I could be assured that there was a 100% chance of complete and utter dryness, I just don’t think I can take the chance. Hopefully this little confession will make me seem less like a creep, but more of a victim of Blimpie’s carelessness. Please don’t judge me for my phobia, I would do anything to eat it. It sounds delicious!

Baby not covered in shit but peanut butter image via citypages.com

(Is there something that you’ve never done that everyone kinda assumes that you would have done? Would you like to confess this in a public forum? Then why don’t you shout about it in a public library, just before closing, ya freak? Yeah – do it, do it DO IT. Okay, if you’d rather write about it in a ready sort of way, then send your confession to mail (at) wordsmoker (dot) com or the older email address I can’t be bothered to reproduce here and my ice cream is melting so get to it, sexy legs.)

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/chillbearlatrigue/ Chillbear Latrigue

    What if we gave you a good old fashioned CIA PB&J sandwich-boarding? Then you could live out your fantasy without fear of the sandwich itself. We can have our lawyers write up the parameters.

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/lipsticklibrarian/ LipstickLibrarian

    We’ll start you on saltines, then work on up to toast.

    And there’s always the Snackmaster, which is kind of like a waffle iron for sandwiches. My grandpa acquired one of these about twenty years ago, and for a few summers thereafter, every time we’d visit we were treated to Snackmastered meals of every conceivable variety, including piping hot PB&Js.

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/chillbearlatrigue/ Chillbear Latrigue

    LsL: Is this anything like the Num Num Snack Factory or the Cornballer (which can only be purchased in Mexico)?

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/fracturedacetabulum/ FracturedAcetabulum

    LL: sounds delish.

    Burt (VWS I have to assume based on the quirky spelling of paedophile): Dude. Get over it. It’s not anal sex. It’s a PBJ. Stop being such a pussy.

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/ladies-and-gentlemen-mrburt-bacharach/ ladies and gentlemen-mr.burt bacharach

    Hmm, I would have to assume that the spell check didn’t pick up pedophile. With VWS do you mean Van der Woude syndrome or Vestas Wind Systems? Had to try to google that one….

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/samuraipandapoetry/ samuraipandapoetry

    Thanks for the great Halloween costume idea.

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/samuraipandapoetry/ samuraipandapoetry

    Also.
    scary peanut butter! ooooh!

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/chillbearlatrigue/ Chillbear Latrigue

    SPP, only you could find scary peanut butter. Bravo, sir.

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/voxpopuli/ VoxPopuli

    I didn’t like peanut butter until I was in college, so this seems normal to me.

    What about toasting bread before you make the PB&J? It wouldn’t taste that different and it wouldn’t be wet bread. The peanut butter would get a little melty if the toast were still warm, but I don’t think the bread would be wet.

    Also, I have a stoner friend who swears by making PB&J in a skillet, like a grilled cheese sandwich. I can’t vouch for that one.

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/voxpopuli/ VoxPopuli

    @Lipstick: ooooh….one of my summer job roomies had that when I was in college. I had grilled cheese sandwiches every day for lunch and they were so good.

  • http://wordsmoker.com/help/members-3/samuraipandapoetry/ samuraipandapoetry

    Vox: PBJ in a skillet? Does not sound great. Grilled cheese in skillet = amazing, but I can’t imagine it translating over to PB and J.